Here are The Shoes that won
The Big Debate. These really are more comfortable and I just really like how they look. I liked them even before I ordered them from
Zappos.com. I was thrilled when they fit AND were comfortable AND went with my dress.

I put the
picture of me wearing my shoes on Facebook as well and got quite the response!
The tally:
Pointy-er shoe: 7 votes
Buckle shoe: 1o votes
Pleas for comfort: 7 votes
One of each: 1 vote
Favorite Comment:
"What? Caleb's getting married??? I need to be caught up! And I vote for the buckle... :0)"(That comment is from a friend I hadn't talked to in eight years and just reconnected with her on Facebook.)